Saturday, November 21, 2026

A Boarding School Series Set in Skye by Mabel Esther Allan

Over the Sea to School – illustrated by W. Mackinlay (1950)
The unfortunately named Dillian, who loves her high school in England, is horrified when her parents decide she should go to boarding school on the Isle of Skye. The air will be bracing for someone recovering from influenza and there is a family connection – the grandmother she never knew came from Skye. Like other fictional heroines, she decides to be so difficult that she will be sent home and at first she hates the school anyway. When she realizes her relatives are poor crofters and the cousin her age actually works at the school, Dillian is snobbishly horrified and hides the fact that they are connected.

Dundonay House is relatively new, progressive school, started by a vibrant young woman who is a native of Skye but was educated elsewhere. It is on a loch on the west part of the island and offers swimming, boating, and hiking rather than traditional school games (this also upsets Dillian who is her school’s captain). Miss Rorison also encourages her students to mix with the locals so it is very awkward when Dillian meets her relatives but her impulsive denial of any connections in Scotland prevents her from backing down. All the villagers are very excited about the return of their ancestral Chief: his father had emigrated to Canada to make a living and the son is now coming back to his ancestral home, but Dillian and her classmates think there is something odd about him and even when they find proof of this, they hesitate to tell the headmistress. You know this won’t end well, at least short term. But eventually the friendliness of the other girls (and her own conscience) force Dillian to embrace school life and admit her relationship to the Harvie family.

A School in Danger – illustrated by Eric Winter (1952)
Thirteen-year-old Vania has spent her whole life in Peru but her mother grew up in Scotland and she is thrilled to be heading to Dundonay House which her cousins already attend. She makes the three week trip with a business colleague of her father’s (going through the Panama Canal, which could have got more than a sentence, Mabel) and traveling to school by train and boat after landing in Liverpool. On the train, Vania meets an unpleasant girl, traveling to Skye with her father, who sneers at her and says she knows a secret about the school:
“Anyway, you’ll know soon enough, I suppose. My father doesn’t like it because it’s so modern; the girls wear slacks in the winter and go to local dances, and get to know the people who live in the poor little crofts round about. And they do just as they like – they don’t have any rules.”
Vania defends her new school and tries not to worry but her immediate love of Dundonay House is overshadowed by horrid Rachel Fox, now staying at a nearby hotel. It turns out Mr. Fox inherited the school property and does not plan to renew the lease: he want to turn it into a sort of Outward Bound for boys. When the school and local residents find out, everyone is horrified and let the Foxes know it. I loved how Vania and her new bestie decide that scaring Rachel by locking her in a hut overnight might discourage the Foxes from staying in Skye. Fortunately, Mr. Fox doesn’t like feeling the whole village is against his project and finds another venue, and Rachel is envious of the girls’ camaraderie and decides she’d rather go to Dundonay House than have a governess, so everyone is happy.
Two of my  books are autographed!  MAE lived in Heswell, a town on the Wirral Peninsula in England, located on the Dee Estuary near Liverpool and Chester.  Her standard habit when signing her personal copies or books for readers was to write her name followed immediately by Heswall, Wirral on the front endpaper or title page.

At School in Skye – illustrated by Constance Marshall (1957)
Vania loved her first term at Dundonay House and is enjoying the winter holidays with her cousins in Scotland when there is terrible news – their beloved headmistress, Miss Rorison, was in a car accident and has arranged for her stepsister, Miss Gowan, to serve as temporary headmistress. Not only does Miss Gowan disapprove of the girls being casually outside hiking and boating in their free time, she takes a strong dislike to harmless Vania. The school is in an uproar and everyone is miserable for months but when flu strikes the cook, the girls all rally around and prepare all the meals for several days. Even Miss Gowan (in bed with flu herself) is impressed, and soon Miss Rorison is back, pale but well enough to assume the reins again. And everyone is delighted that she has become engaged to the Chief!

This is a fun series! I think Girls Gone By has reprinted all of these recently so you might find a copy online.

Author: Mabel Esther Allan
Genre: Juvenile school stories
Source: Personal copies
MAE reviews: Lost Lorrenden, The Rising Tide, Catrin in Wales, Do Your Favorite Authors Know Each Other?

No comments: