Saturday, October 20, 2018

Young Bess (Guest Book Review) #1944Club

When I realized that my mother’s favorite book, Young Bess, was published in 1944, I asked her to contribute a review for the 1944 Club, in which Simon from Stuck in a Book and Karen from Kaggsy's Bookish Ramblings promote a specific year of published books.

Title: Young Bess
Author: Margaret Irwin
Publication: 1944
Genre: Historical Fiction

The original cover
Recently there has been a spate of novels about the Tudors, especially Henry VIII and his wives. And, of course, Elizabeth I as queen has been extremely visible in fiction, on stage, in opera.  More unusual is the vivid portrait of Elizabeth as a vulnerable girl in Margaret Irwin’s memorable book, Young Bess. It begins in 1546 with the 12-year-old Bess on the ship Great Harry with Henry and his entourage, and ends eight years later at the death of her young brother Edward VI. In between she copes with loneliness, treachery, and dangerous rumors about her relationship with her stepmother’s husband, all the while learning how to survive and eventually to rule. There are many well drawn characters, such as her kind stepmother Catherine Parr, her feisty governess, Cat Ashley, her tutor, Roger Ascham, and the noblemen jostling for power over the boy king.
The book is scrupulously accurate; that is, it makes good use of the historical evidence, and doesn’t go far afield. Obviously, we cannot know what Elizabeth’s thoughts were, or what actually went on between her and Thomas Seymour. But if there are to be historical novels featuring real people, this is a model. Margaret Irwin went on to write two more novels about Bess: Elizabeth, Captive Princess (how her sister Mary imprisoned her in the Tower) and Elizabeth and the Prince of Spain (well, you know that part.) They are very good, but Young Bess rules.
A more recent cover (the popular headless look)
A personal note: somehow I discovered this adult novel in fourth grade. From that moment I was fascinated by the period, and went on to read the rest of the trilogy and much more, and to choose as my college major the Renaissance and Reformation. In England long afterward I saw the original of a letter Bess wrote in 1548. It was a thrill, especially since I had known it word for word since I was ten.

Source: First edition/personal copy
Deborah Kerr was originally to play Elizabeth
in the 1953 MGM movie but wound up as Catherine Parr 
Stephanie Martin


Sara said...

I read Young Bess in grade school too! The fictional Tudor-related biography that stuck with me the most though was Jan Westcott's The Queen's Grace, which is about Katharine Parr. I don't know how Westcott's work stacks up against Irwin's for historical accuracy but both authors produced a lot of good historical fiction.

Simon T (StuckinaBook) said...

How wonderful that our club year matched her favourite book! Thanks for participating :)

Helen said...

I really enjoyed this book, so it's good to read your mother's thoughts on it. I'm looking forward to working through the rest of Irwin's novels now.

Katrina said...

I've just ordered the third book, having just finished the second one. I haven't read any other books by Irwin but certainly plan to do so now.